Shutdown delays October data; analysts look elsewhere
TINA PARKER ARKANSAS DEMOCRAT-GAZETTE
Faced with a lack of reports from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, analysts and farmers have turned to the private sector to obtain information about grain and livestock trade.
The USDA is closed because of the government shutdown, and its monthly crop report was not released last week. The crop report is the predominant source of information on agriculture supply and demand and is used to forecast market direction.
Urner Barry, a private company that has been in the protein-market-reporting business for 155 years, has obtained many new customers since the shutdown began. Joe Muldowney, vice president of Urner Barry, said the company has reporters who complete market reports, which normally coincide with USDA reports.
“People are looking for that information from a timely, accurate and unbiased source, and that’s why a lot of people came to us after the shutdown,” he said.
Despite private analysts’ data, Dan Cekander, director of grain-market analysis for Newedge USA, LLC, said the delay of the October crop report — which would have been issued at the end of last week — has created uncertainty.
“We missed one of the key production reports of the year,” Cekander said. “We spent all this time estimating, and we are getting to the harvest and finally finding out how much is out there and we don’t know the production numbers.”
Gary Blumenthal, president of World Perspectives Inc., an agricultural consulting firm, said USDA information is vital.
“Reports that the USDA issues are taken with great seriousness and millions of dollars are made or lost,” Blumenthal said. “For one, the information provides certainty and it provides legal construct, which gives lower volatility and less upheaval in the commodity market.”
He said that though there is a lack of data, it is a less risky time for a shutdown because farmers are coming out of a harvest.
“My estimate is this, it is probably having a less adverse impact than if it were in June and crops would rely on reports,” Blumenthal said.
Cekander disagreed.
“There are a lot of anecdotal reports from the yield and high numbers are being passed around,” Cekander said, adding that October gives the true direction of the yield.
“There’s not enough data in September to give enough of a yield direction — it’s just more accurate and that’s why we need the October report,” he said.
Without the concrete data, the information from analysts is speculation and could be confirmed or discounted when the government reopens.
Publication: Arkansas Democrat-Gazette; Date: Oct 16, 2013; Section: Business; Page: 25